Showing posts with label IBCC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IBCC. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

A Need for More Regional Water Management Organizations


Here is a reprint of a memorandum to the then IBCC members of the Metro Basin Roundtable Chips Barry and Doug Scott (with copies to Harris Sherman and Eric Hecox) from one of the Metro Roundtable members, Tracy Bouvette, dated March 5, 2008

I applaud Executive Director Sherman’s request that those in the Colorado Water Community step back from the current focus on water projects, and articulate their vision of Colorado in the future. It is entirely appropriate to have our State’s leaders frame any discussions regarding the cooperative expenditures of billions of taxpayer dollars in terms of where Colorado is and where it is going. This is not to say that without a collective vision we cannot pursue new water development projects, but it is vital that we collectively identify what is important to us as a State as we continue to share the most precious resources that drive our future economic and social well-being.

One key driver in Colorado’s future economy is obviously home sales: not just homes for our working families, but second homes for those that enjoy our State’s natural beauty and want to live part-time in Colorado. We put a great deal of value in having more homes built in Colorado, based on the ongoing and explosive growth supported in many geographies of the State, including the Front Range and headwater areas alike. We also should expect to see substantial growth in areas that will likely foster increasingly larger retirement communities like the Durango and Grand Junction areas. Growth is a mantra for many of our local economies, and that is generally associated with the growth of housing units and related services.

Does housing alone provide for the State’s economic needs of the future? Of course not. Jobs that survive in the long-term will need to be tied to other industries to keep Colorado vibrant and healthy – jobs that bring money into the State from those individuals that benefit from our natural resources and food stock; as well as jobs that compliment and support the needs of the local community.

Current jobs in tourism, manufacturing, professional services, agriculture and exploration of our natural resources (e.g., fossil fuels and minerals) will clearly be the linch-pin of our State’s future – particularly in those regions where natural and existing resources are available to support these jobs. Which of these areas of employment will grow in the future is not clear; however, each category has its own opportunity for growth. For example, we have become increasingly dependant on tourism to provide for seasonal and year-round jobs, create sale tax revenue to support local economies, and bring full-time residents and businesses to our State. We are blessed with breathtaking scenery in nearly every corner of the State, with increasing demands on us to deliver natural wonders to the world’s ever increasing population. To this point, we saw tourist trips (as domestic overnight trips) increase by 8% from 2005 to 2006 as the world came to enjoy our State’s natural wonders, parks, and other attractions. This is a trend that will continue as the State and our local governments continue to spend money advertising nationwide and abroad, luring tourists to our mountains and cities.

However, tourism is only a $14 billion industry in Colorado, making up about 6% of the State’s gross domestic product (GDP). On the other hand, seven of the top ten private employers in the State provide either goods (i.e., Walmart, Target, Safeway and Kroger) or health services (i.e., Exempla, Centura Health, and HCA – Health Services) (based on 2006 data). We are, in fact, very dependant on small businesses that support the local, regional and national service industry. To this point, information services (including telecom, internet services, software development and advertising) and professional services (including legal and engineering) represent nearly 32% of the State’s GDP. People move to Colorado to live and work in our magnificent State because of our natural resources and vast public lands, and presumably our moderate climate . Our ability to maintain, and where possible enhance, our public lands and provide enjoyable outdoor recreation opportunities will go hand in glove with our ability to continue to attract service industry jobs to our State. It would, therefore appear that the protection of the State’s environment including the appropriate maintenance, and where possible enhancement, of instream environmental and recreational flows will become increasingly important to draw these jobs to Colorado.

There is a great deal of optimisms regarding the potential for expanded oil and gas exploration in Colorado as a means to drive growth. Exploration of fossil fuels on the Roan Plateau and in the Piceance Basin, exploration and production in the southwestern portions of the State, as well in various other locations is expected to drive substantial growth of communities especially along the middle and lower Colorado River. Although mining and oil and gas exploration produced about $13 million toward the State’s GDP (about 5.6%), this economic sector is expected to grow to such proportions as to rival the information and professional services industries. However, development of the oil and gas resources will require a substantial amount of water to support drilling and exploration activities, for example. Produced water disposal, impacting stream flow quantities and qualities, will also create challenges for future water resources management. Therefore, the expected growth of this economic sector will need to be balanced with the values and needs of the information and professional services community, the agricultural community, as well as with second home owners - to name a few - such that the economic well-being of those impacted regions are not compromised.

Manufacturing is also important to our State’s economy providing about $15 million to our GDP. We provide manufacturing to a broad range of buyers creating products that include industrial and electrical machinery, medical and surgical instruments, aircraft and spacecraft and related parts, organic chemicals and plastics, etc. We should expect that these jobs, while they may change with respect to specific products, will always be needed to support our local and regional economy. Additional manufacturing jobs may also be created as renewable energy opportunities are explored.

More people coming to Colorado, of course, means that we need more fuel and food to support the population. This shines a bright light on the importance of agriculture, mining, and renewable energy to our State’s regional and local economies. All of these three industries are vital to the future sustainable health of Colorado. We are blessed with fertile lands, rich oil and gas deposits, and renewable energy sources. Reaping the benefits of these riches will be a required component of any durable vision of Colorado.

Therefore, future water development will need to provide the reliable, safe, high quality water needed to support all of our needs, including:

Tourism and the natural environment to continue to bring money into the State from beyond our borders and to draw more permanent residents to our growing residential areas;

Municipal and industrial water supply for our working and service industry communities, our headwaters communities, and our retirement communities;
Agriculture such that food for our citizens can be grown and consumed without substantial implications on our carbon production, while at the same time creating jobs and supporting local economies (noting that agriculture also has an important role in State tourism as agritourism grows); and
Mining and oil and gas exploration to support ongoing and future mineral exploration in various locations across the State.

Clearly, future water development will require that a complex balance be struck between these vital, yet competing demands.

What is unclear is whether or not the parochial nature of Colorado’s water provider community can effectively meet the challenge of balancing these various and oft times competing water demands. Perhaps the greater question that needs to be clarified is not how can we work more collaboratively to balance the future water needs of these competing demands, but rather, do we have a system of governments and special districts that can effectively share and manage our resources to the benefit of all our diverse needs? It may be that the best solution for appropriately managing and allocating Colorado’s water given the competing demands and the need to preserve and protect all the key elements of the State’s economic resources will require some structural changes to how we build and operate large water projects.

With respect to those key issues raised in Executive Director Sherman’s January 15th Memo regarding the “economic base in each region” and how the “business as usual” scenario will impact our future water supply needs, it is likely that unless the status quo changes, water supply development (and even substantial amounts of saved water from water conservation efforts) will be used to support new homes in Colorado’s various geographies without appropriately balancing other vital consumptive and non-consumptive water needs – needs that support robust, resilient communities with diversified local and regional economies buoyed by long-term jobs that match the locally available resources and the related demand for goods and services. We see the majority of water development occurring at this time is to support growth, and there is no reason to expect that fact to substantially change without some degree of intervention or structural revision.

Municipal water providers, after all, are simply doing their job. It is no fault of these organizations that certain water uses are not necessarily equally represented in future water supply development and related financing discussions. Water projects require water sales to support debt service payments. These organizations are limited by their charters, by-laws and other organizational constraints, such that water resources management on a regional and/or statewide scale can become a patch work of intergovernmental agreements and memorandums of understanding, or worse, be regulatory driven.

What appears to be needed, therefore, are organizations with the authority and fiduciary responsibility to manage and allocate water resources to support a broader and more diversified set of uses such that some balance can be ascertained to support long-term economic needs beyond simply providing water for growth and/or municipal and industrial supplies - without creating “winners” and “losers.” Regional water management organizations, such as exist in Nevada, Arizona and California, may therefore be a vital component of our future water supply vision allowing for more representative and holistic management of our State’s water resources.

    [1] America’s Best States, 2nd (National Policy Research Council); Most Preferred State to Live in, 4th (Harris Poll); Best Places to Live, various rankings for different cities (Money Magazine); Parks and Recreation, 6th (National Association of Parks Directors)

    Monday, September 15, 2008

    Another IBCC Discussion and the Federal Government

    The role and effectiveness of the Interbasin Ccmpact Commission (IBCC) continues to receive substantial discussion at high levels across Colorado. For good reason. Legislators are becoming entrenched in the process; regualtors are receiving funding to keep the process going; and dozens and dozens of individuals and organizations are committing thousands of volunteer hours to keep the dialogue moving.

    To the credit of the current administration, the discussion and related work products have been moved forward to a point never before conceived - in that most major basins have established true "needs assessments" that are framed in a consistent manner - utilizing available data to identify water supply needs based on expected water demands, past river administration, and currently identified projects and processes that local and regional planning entities have developed. Bravo. The discussion has also been recently framed by a collective visioning effort that has received substantial buy-in from a wide geography of users with seemingly diverse water interests including environmental groups. Double bravo.

    However, one key stakeholder appears not to be at the table in a manner that is meaningful and required. That is the largest single landowner in the state that controls, to some extent, the majority of the land from which our water supply is derived - that being the Federal government. Certainly the local National Forest Service and Parks Service, as well as BLM and BRec, staff have been included in the discussion, but no key Federal decision-maker is a member of the IBCC.

    This may be by design. But is it a key failing in the effort of identifying the future vision for the state, and the related water needs, if the key land owner is not present?

    Their is a reasonable argument both ways regarding inclusion of the Federal government. There are good reasons for Colorado's citizens to try and work through the various thorny issues without the 800 pound gorilla in the room, since we have a number of local and regional issues that only we can identify and characterize. The needs assessment, for example, which looks at needs, does not as of yet deal with estimating watershed yields - that is another study (at least for the Colorado River). So having no federal representation helps to ease the discussions and allow (perhaps) for a more open sharing of ideas and concerns.

    But not having the Federal government hinders development of any true resolution to key issues like managing beetle kill areas, or impacts of large fires, or evaluating forest management techniques to improve forest health while increasing watershed yield.

    "Despite being portrayed as a villain, timber harvesting in the form of thinning can substantially counteract the impact of fire regrowth on water yield. The benefits of regrowth thinning have been widely studied throughout Australia. In Melbourne's catchments, strip-thinning trials have shown that up to 2.5 million litres a year of additional run-off can be generated from each hectare of thinned regrowth. A program of thinning the 1939 regrowth could add billions of litres of water to our storages.

    Western Australia has been quicker to take advantage of thinning as a water management tool. Earlier this year, a $20 million, 12-year thinning program was initiated in a substantial segment of Perth's catchment following four years of exhaustive public and stakeholder consultation. Every 1,000 hectares thinned is expected to deliver an additional one billion litres of run-off into the Wungong Dam a year."

    This is an extract from an opinion piece by Mark Poynter first published in The Age and just republished by On Line Opinion, entitled 'Fired-up Forests, Have More Impact Than the Loggers'. Read the full article here: http://www.onlineopinion.com.au/view.asp?article=5213

    Interesting, quite a bit of the research prepared to discuss the relationship between forest management and watershed yield is somewhat aged (see New Mexico SEO Literature Listing), but it does exist. No doubt Colorado State University is looking at this as this is written (as well as other State schools).

    Another key issue that Colorado's water providers and interests on the IBCC are going to have to face is who is going to pay for the expected future water supply projects, which include everything from structural storage to instream restorations to species management and protection. I have heard figures as high as $6 billion just for infrastructure will be needed by 2030, but their are others that likely have a more accurate number than that. If $6 billion is close, then what is the infrastructure cost from 2030 to 2050? Another $6 billion? $10 billion. We just aren't used to talking about these kinds of costs.

    To wit, funding for the kinds of projects currently being discussed by the IBCC is not going to be easily raised without some kind of Federal support. Any project that includes federal lands, wetlands or waterways with Federal jurisdiction, and/or federal facilities will also carry a need for Federal dollars to support planning and evaluation efforts. This further indicates that relative importance and value of having Federal organizations involved upfront in the planning and analyses that are ongoing within the State. We simply are going to need their help.

    The bottom line is that meaningful progress on this as well as numerous other issues with a Federal nexus will need to be addressed head on for the IBCC to get to closure - closure meaning a resolution to more sustainable water supply for the current and future citizens of Colorado. The Federal government, especially the Department of the Interior, but perhaps the US Army Corps of Engineers, and the US EPA may also need to be "on the team" earlier, rather than later, to help us get solutions that are both feasible and timely.

    Just my two cents.

    Tuesday, August 26, 2008

    Interbasin Basin Compact Commission and Water Conservation


    The Interbasin Compact Commission (IBCC) of Colorado has made some significant strides related to creating a dialogue and planning for the State's water future. This is of course no small task given the State's history of parochial water development and east slope/west slope animosity. There are dozens of examples of cooperative water projects, but there are numerous other examples of unjust water grabs and unintended consequences related to dam and diversion construction detrimentally impacting environmental settings and local economies to give forward thinking people pause. To this point, the IBCC has taken on, as at least one of its goals, to open the water dialogue to broader interests and more inclusive water uses. Bravo.

    Unfortunately, water conservation has taken a back seat in this effort. This is not to say that many water providers and water users in the State do not take water conservation seriously,... many do. But surprisingly, a vast number of the State's water providers - municipalities and special districts - do not appear to take water conservation seriously evidenced by the lack of these entities developing meaningful water conservation plans using the guidelines and requirements set forth in Colorado Statute. Meaningful water conservation plans allow for the setting of water conservation goals and the tracking of successful water savings in a manner that is clearly needed for Colorado to best manage its current and future allocations of water resources in the best and most earnest manner. Without meaningful water conservation plans and the water savings that occur as a result of careful and thoughtful planning, it is difficult for the State to represent its actions in a consistent and consciencious manner to our citizens and to those states that we share in the use of the water transported by our rivers and streams.

    Should the State develop more stringent standards and requirements for local water conservation planning and implementation? That is a tricky question, since it is clearly undesirable to create statute that requires local utilities and special districts to commit resources to water conservation that they lack. Due to the TABOR amendments, some utilites and special districts are hard pressed to find general fund monies that could be used for such activities. Although the State has created a nearly $3 million grant program to support local water conservation planning and implementation, pursuing and implementing planning still requires local resources. On the other hand, programs that are based on State regulatory requirements cannot be dismissed by City Councils and Special District Boards as being voluntary and/or unnecessary. Having State requirements can therefore take away the guess work that staff can face at a local level when approaching appointed and/or elected officials.

    There is no easy answer. However, it would appear that the IBCC needs to take a more explicit stance reqarding the value and importance of water conservation planning when looking at water development projects that have regional and/or statewide signficance. For example, the Northern Integrated Supply Plan (NISP) has run into opposition due to the potential impact on the Cache la Poudre, and the perception that local municipalities are not planning for and implementing aggressive enough water conservation programs. Interesting that most of the municipalities that would benefit from NISP have yet to complete their water conservation plans. This is not a good thing.

    Similarly, the reallocation of Chatfield Reservoir storage from flood pool to water supply storage requires federal permitting and approval. Numerous front range communities stand to gain important storage from this project within an existing storage facility, yet many of the project stakeholders and benefactors have not completed water conservation plans consistent with the State statutes. Given that the Chatfield project has been on the books for over 15 years, and that substantial work has been conducted on the EIS since 2004, it is difficult to understand the mindset of those water providers that have not developed water conservation plans in advance of the EIS preparation and approval process. Some have, but not all.

    Isn't getting the entire team to work together in a consistent and beneficial manner one of the goals of the IBCC? It seems like a natural fit. However it has been an unpopular role given that it would require all water users to work as a team and truly share resources, and at times commit resources to the benefit of the larger outcome, not just the needs of the few. It remains to be seen how the overall water needs of the Front Range will be served through the IBCC process. From this writer's perspective, the IBCC is a great idea that will continue to ferment and solidify into the future. However, it may be that unless the IBCC develops strong, and at times unpopular, stands regarding some of the thornier water issues, such as the need for widespread, meaningful (and therefore measurable) water conservation, the overall process will fail. A house divided against itself cannot stand,... and a group of water providers operating in manners inconsistent with the needs of the larger community will similarly fail.